A Pat McAfee Jersey therefore carries a different kind of appeal. It connects classic Colts blue-and-white identity with a player whose impact extended beyond his position. McAfee earned Pro Bowl and All-Pro recognition in 2014, while his career included numerous Indianapolis punting records.

For collectors, this is less about following a current roster and more about preserving a memorable chapter of Colts culture. The No. 1 look gives the collection a distinctive character, making it a strong choice for fans who appreciate Indianapolis football history with a personality-driven edge.